Fiqhul Ibiadat, by Durriyah Aita

PART THREE › THE BOOK OF PRAYER › Congregational prayer (JAMA'A) › Legal status of congregational prayer › The legal status of congregational prayer when the imam's actions are not being followed

Find in page

1- Physical actions:

-a- Performing the prayer's actions simultaneously with the imam.

It is makrooh, though it does not invalidate the prayer, to perform a prayer's action simultaneously with the imam and the merit of congregational prayer is lost.

-b- Performing the prayer's actions ahead of the imam.

It is forbidden, though the congregational prayer remains valid if one

completely finishes a physical pillar before the imam gets to it.

As when one bows and then straightens up while the imam is still standing.

It is makrooh to do a physical pillar partially ahead of the imam, as when one bows before the imam does and waits for him to bow then raises his head.

This does not invalidate the prayer be it done intentionally or absentmindedly because it is a slight contravention.

Abu Hurayrah (G. p. H) narrated that the Prophet (P. B. U. H) said:

"Isn't he who raises his head before the imam afraid that Allah (G. B. H) may transform his head into that of a donkey's!"

[Al-Bukhari, Vol. 1, The Book of Congregational Prayer and the Inmate, Chapter 25/659].

If one does so intentionally, then he is recommended, though not obligated, to return to standing and bow with the imam.

If one absentmindedly bows before the imam does, he has the choice to return to standing or remain where he is and in both cases one does not miss the merit of congregational prayer.

It invalidates one's prayer to complete, without excuse, two physical pillars (even if not long (Short rukns are straightening up from bowing and sitting between prostrations, any other rukn is considered long) before the imam does, as when one prostrates while the imam is still standing reciting Quran, because by doing so one lacks the following of the imam's leadership which he is ordered to have.

If one does so for a valid excuse, it does not invalidate the prayer and one does not lose the reward of the congregational prayer. (pa: 225)

The valid excuses for going ahead of the imam are forgetting and ignorance of the jurisprudence of such intricate matters.

-c- Lagging behind the imam.

If there is no excuse, it does not invalidate one's prayer, though it is makrooh, to lag behind the imam until he completely finishes a physical pillar.

It invalidates one's prayer to lag behind the imam until he finishes two physical pillars because following the imam's leadership is impaired.

When one lags behind the imam for a valid excuse, one's prayer is not

invalidated, the merit of congregational prayer is not lost, and one is entitled to lag in order to finish the obligatory recital (and that includes only the Fatiha) after which one rapidly performs the elements of his own prayer to catch up with the imam, provided the imam in not more than three long pillars ahead of one.

If one is farther behind than that, then one follows the imam's leadership (as a latecomer does) from where one is and performs what one has missed after the imam finishes with salam, or one parts from praying with the imam.

One's prayer is invalid if the imam begins the fifth pillar while one is still reciting unless one parts from praying with the imam.

The valid excuses for lagging behind the imam are:

1- One's slow recital due to one's inability (to recite quicker) or unfounded misgivings, while the imam's recital is average in its speed.

2- The imam being fast in his recital.

3- A latecomer (who stands with the imam for a time enough to recite the Fatiha or more) being occupied with performing a sunna such as the opening supplication.

In this case one may lag behind in order to finish the

Fatiha if he has not.

4- Absentmindedness. If after the imam bows and before one does, one is uncertain as to whether he recited the Fatiha or not, or recalls that he has not, one must lag behind the imam in order to recite it.

If this occurs after one has bowed, one need not return to recite it, rather one follows the imam and performs a rak'a after the imam finishes with salam.

2- Verbal pillars:

-a- It invalidates one's prayer to say one's opening takbir simultaneously with the imam or ahead of the imam because in this case one links one's prayer to the imam's before his is established.

Abu Hurayrah (G. p. H) narrated that the prophet (P. B. U. H) said:

"The imam is to be followed, after he says the opening takbir then you say it, and do not say it until he does".

[Abu Dawood, Vol. 1, The Book of Prayer, Chapter 69/603].

Also, it invalidates one's prayer to be uncertain as to whether one did say one's opening takbir simultaneously with the imam or not, or to think one said it after the imam did but it was simultaneous. (pa: 226)

It is a necessary condition that all of one's takbirs take place after all of the imam's.

-b- It is makrooh to say one's salam simultaneously with the imam, yet one does not lose the merit of the congregational prayer.

-C- In silent prayers, it is valid to finish reciting the Fatiha or the testification of faith before the imam begins because doing so is not an apparent differing.

-d- In aloud prayers, it is makrooh to recite the Fatiha simultaneously with the imam and one thereby loses the merit of congregational prayer in this particular pillar.

A latecomer (who stands with the imam for a time not long enough to recite the Fatiha) is recommended not to perform a sunna such as the opening supplication or ta'awwuth, rather he immediately starts reciting the Fatiha which is an obligation that no other non-obligatory act should distract from, unless he thinks he has time to recite it after performing the sunna.

If he performs a sunna he is obligated to lag behind the imam and recite a part of the Fatiha equal to the performed sunna because he is blamed with neglecting an obligation in favor of a non-obligation.

If, after he finishes, he joins the imam in bowing, this rak'a counts for him, but it does not if he joins the imam in straightening up in which case he must follow the imam and then perform a rak'a when the imam finishes with salam.

A latecomer must part from praying with the imam if the imam moves to prostrate before the latecomer finishes his recital, If he does not or

prostrates with the imam his prayer becomes invalid.

A latecomer who did not occupy his time with a sunna is obligated to bow with the imam and is entitled to omit the rest of the Fatiha and the rak'a counts for him because following the imam is essential.

If he lags behind the imam in order to finish the Fatiha until the imam straightens up from bowing, he misses the rak'a because he lagged for no excuse, but his prayer is valid.

In this case, he follows the imam and prostrates with him as if he has just joined the imam at this point and his first rak'a does not count for him.